15 Best Pizza Places in Columbus, Ohio (2023)

Looking for the best pizza places in Columbus, Ohio? You’re in luck! We’ve compiled a list of the top spots to get your fix.

Whether you’re into a thin crust or deep dish, these places have something for everyone. So what are you waiting for? Check out our list and start planning your next pizza night!

1. Terita’s Pizza

• Address: 3905 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH 43224
• Phone: (614) 475-2100

Family-owned and run for over 50 years, this pizza, sub, and wing carry-out is a local institution. Numerous customers consider Terita’s among the top pizza joints in Columbus because of its traditional style. Are you ready to sample the finest Italian Columbus has to offer? If so, it’s time for some takeout pizza from Terita’s. They top the list of best pizza places in Columbus, to eat.

You won’t find many other places in Columbus that match their expertise in making authentic Italian food. In a flash, you can have it delivered to your door via services like UberEats and dig in without leaving the house. You won’t be able to stop at just one order of their oven-roasted plain, bbq, or spicy wings. Spicy peppers, meatballs, spaghetti sauce, and Provolone cheese top off their Meatball Sub.

2. GoreMade Pizza

• Address: 936 N 4th St, Columbus, OH 43201
• Phone: (614) 725-2115

The restaurant serves wood-fired pizzas with a variety of toppings, as well as local beer and beverages. They are a Columbus-based eatery and a mobile wood-fired pizza business inspired by a love of great pizza. It’s a pizza delivery place with a few seats inside. Patrons frequently cite happy hour, excellent service, and delicious food. With its open layout, the kitchen encourages conversation among guests. The international Italian dome oven can be viewed from every seat in the house, competing for the best pizza in Columbus.

In the back, you’ll find a colorful patio complete with a cool art car. The decor encourages such intimate get-togethers. Only six toppings are offered consistently throughout the year, and the rest of the time, the selection is entirely seasonal. Fresh mozzarella cheese is included with every pizza order. Normal toppings include feta, red onion, roasted mushrooms, bacon, sausage, and pepperoni.

3. The Pizza House

• Address: 747 East Lincoln Ave, Columbus, Ohio
• Phone: (614) 885-3121

A basic, well-lit diner serving Italian cuisines like pasta, pizza, and meatball subs. Since its opening in 1961, this pizza joint has been serving up fresh pizzas and the friendliest, most helpful service in the area.

They’re pleased with how their company has developed alongside Columbus throughout the years. The proprietors said they would have no desire to live anywhere else and owe a great debt to the community for making their dream of opening a pizza parlor a reality. Business catering is something they specialize in, so you can trust them to handle the details of your event. When they cater to your corporate event, your guests will receive the finest cuisine the city has to offer!

4. East Coast Pizzeria

• Address: 5060 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214
• Phone: (614) 885-0101

Diners praise East Coast Pizzeria’s welcoming ambiance and child-friendly offerings. Brick-oven pizza, flatbreads, and more are what they do best at East Coast Pizzeria. The dough for our pizza is rolled out by hand and then baked in a brick oven until it’s a lovely golden color and the cheese and toppings are melted and bubbly. East Coast Pizzeria has the pizza you’ve been looking for if you’re tired of the same old pizza places.

The East Coast Italian Sub is a great choice if you’re in the mood for a sub. It comes piled high with Italian dressing, banana peppers, tomatoes, red onions, lettuce, loop pepperoni, Provolone, salami, capicola, and ham. All of the subs are served on white Italian sub buns with sautéed vegetables. Every single sub is roasted.

5. Dewey’s Pizza

• Address: 1327 W 5th Ave, Columbus, OH 43212
• Phone: (614) 487-8282

Dewey’s Pizza is a chain of 24 restaurants serving gourmet pizza in an elegant, informal setting across the Midwest. They have been serving up delicious pizza, salads, and craft beers from the area for over twenty years. Their friendly service, paired with the tunes from a curated playlist, is what sets them apart and elevates the pizza experience to the next level.

Their store network extends to many cities along the East Coast. You can have a delicious pizza night with the family or on your own. Catering is also available in addition to lunch, supper, and dessert. The warm, welcoming, and laid-back ambiance is a big hit with regulars.

6. Aracri Pizzeria (Campus)

• Address: 1607 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201
• Phone: (614) 754-7925

Located in Columbus, Aracri Pizzeria is a family-run Italian restaurant focused on pizza. Aracri Pizzeria, established in 1992, has provided Columbus with genuine Italian cuisine and pizza thanks to its founding principles of Big Family and Good Food. Acri is widely considered to be among the top pizza joints in Columbus due to its delicious handmade sauce and crust.

Columbus has no better place to find the best pizza and Italian food. Enjoy sauce & garlic, pasta, and pizza from a family that has been honing their recipes in Columbus for over three decades at either of their two restaurants, one on the OSU campus and the other in the heart of the city on Gay St. Place a takeout order or dine in to experience why Aracari is the best pizza place in town. After 4 p.m., entire pies and deep-fried calzones will be the stars of the supper menu.

7. Fibonacci’s Pizzeria

• Address: 3055 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH 43202
• Phone: (614) 262-7505

Studios 35 has a fantastic local pizza joint. In their 700° F oven, they create pizzas in a Neopolitan manner. This oven temperature produces the best bread and crust for pizza. Their pizzas are a lot of fun to eat and will satisfy your pizza desire. Enjoy a craft beer and pizza at the bar before ordering in for a movie night at home.

The Pizza Monday specials place them in the running for the best pizza in Columbus. We highly recommend the Hot Swarm pizza. The crust is consistently fantastic, managing to be both crispy and airy, plus the tomato sauce is never overly sweet. An excellent value for an 8-slice, 12-inch pizza.

Also read:

• 15 Best Pizza Places in Memphis, Tennessee (2022)
• 15 Best Pizza Places in Chicago, Illinois (2022)
• 15 Best Pizza Places in Atlanta, Georgia (2022)
• 15 Best Pizza Places in Houston, Texas (2022)

8. Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza

• Address: 1618 Neil Ave, Columbus, OH 43201
• Phone: (614) 421-2300

Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza in Columbus has earned a reputation for serving up some of the city’s finest examples of American cuisine. Great flavor is what they specialize in. We’re excited about taking the finest New York and Sicilian-style pizza to Columbus and the Buckeye Family. Customers keep returning for more of their famous chicken wings and the 18 beers on tap.

In addition to its modern decor, which includes cushioned booths, brick walls, classic portraits of Buckeye sports legends, and enough televisions to run a sports bar, Adriatico’s also features a mural of Ohio on one wall, presumably depicting every city in the state. Most evenings are extremely busy, but the helpful wait staff keeps their spirits up and allows customers to put their orders at the bar while waiting for a table. Easily among the best pizza place in Columbus.

9. Rubino’s Pizza

• Address: 2643 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43209
• Phone: (614) 235-0712

If you ask anyone where to get the best pizza in Columbus, without fail, they will mention Rubino’s Pizza. Everyone in the family will love their special pizza sauce, excellent pizza crust, and delicious pasta. Locals go to the thin-crust pizza and casual Italian food at Rubino’s Pizza, a cash-only pizzeria famous in the area. Rubinos has been a Bexley institution for almost 60 years, serving up thin-crust pizza with a crunchy crust and a no-frills, classic vibe.

They are a cash-only business. Pizza that is both thin and tasty. This reminded me of pizza in Italy. That whole huge pizza with extra cheese was delicious. On some days, you can order your favorite pizza and eat it at home. Parking is easy to find and access. Excellent service, both in-store and over the phone, and very pleasant staff. The price is fair for some of the best pizza.

10. Rotolo’s Pizza

• Address: 1749 W 5th Ave, Columbus, OH 43212
• Phone: (614) 488-7934

Carry out the only location of a family-owned pizza, sub, and pasta company with minimal frills.

You can find Rotolo’s Pizza in Columbus, and it is owned and operated by a friendly family. They opened our doors in Columbus in 1974 and have been a staple ever since. The Columbus Dispatch, Columbus Monthly, and ColumbusCitySearch.com have all named their pizza the best in Columbus.

One edition of Los Angeles Magazine even named them one of the country’s top ten pizzerias. Their pizza offers a nice medium-thickness crust, tangy sauce, and flavorful pepperoni. Overall, it’s a good deal for the quality and authenticity of Italian food. Spaghetti dinners come with a little salad, Italian bread, and their special hot cheese blend. The Tutto (Everything) pizza is a best-seller because it combines banana pepper, onion, green pepper, sausage, mushroom, and pepperoni.

11. The Original Josie’s Pizza

• Address: 894 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43222
• Phone: (614) 224-9637

The Original Josie’s Pizza is renowned in Columbus for its thin crust and Italian sub. The long-closed Franklinton pizza joint has reopened. Officially known as Josie’s, the new restaurant is located just a few blocks east of the initial eatery at 894 W. Broad St. Fans of the original Josie’s will be pleased to know that the restaurant is still run by the Catalina family. Even the phone number has been maintained!

You may also assume the pizza to be consistent with previous visits. Austin Catalina, son of Josie’s owner Jason, claims in a video posted to the pizza parlor’s Facebook page that his father still uses the same recipe and that the restaurant’s original ovens are still in use. Use your Uber or other delivery service account when you need the best pizza in Columbus delivered from Josie’s.

12. Hounddog’s Pizza

• Address: 2657 N High St, Columbus, OH 43202
• Phone: (614) 261-4686

A mile from Ohio State, in a quaint storefront, Houmddog’s Pizza serves you original pizzas, traditional subs, and dozens of beers. Hounddog’s Pizza is different from the rest because of the wide selection of toppings available. Starting with the crust, you have your pick of gluten-free, Smokin’ Joe’s style, or our very own thin crust. There are several excellent options, but Smokin’ Joe’s is the most popular.

Finally, there are the sauces, which range from sweet and mild to hot and sour. In case the vast array of customization options feels overwhelming, you can always pick one of the unique specialty pizzas instead. It’s hard to choose between the BBQ chicken pie, the pesto pie, and the hot mama pie, but they’re all fantastic. The pizza place is suitable for the whole family.

13. Brenz Pizza Co. Columbus

• Address: 1551 Lennox Town Ln, Columbus, OH 43212
• Phone: (614) 928-9361

Fresh ingredients, century-old recipes, friendly staff, delicious pizzas, subs, wings, and salads are what define Brenz Pizza. In 2008, Robert Giuliani and Scott Morse combined their Italian heritage with their respective upbringings in New York and Columbus to make the best pizza possible. They contributed a wealth of knowledge gained over many years in the food sector and enlisted the help of loved ones to do numerous rounds of testing, tweaking, and simplifying.

In 2014, they introduced the Brenz Pizza Co. concept, which has been met with resounding praise from pizza lovers. Each year, Brenz has taken first place in national contests. Also, Brenz attended the World Pizza Championship in Parma, Italy, in 2017, where he represented the United States with honor. Easily some of the best pizza in Columbus – hands down!

14. Paulie Gee’s

• Address: 1195 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201
• Phone: (614) 808-0112

This is the first stop for the critically regarded pizza place. Paulie Gee’s Short North is a wood-fired pizza joint serving both Paulie Gee’s original pies and new creations inspired by the tastes of the local community. Check out the Hellboy, along with the soup, beer, and pizza. The pizza specials and beer list are hot topics among the patrons, placing them on the list of the best pizza in Columbus.

Paulie Gee’s is a comfortable and welcoming hangout spot because of its plentiful seating, friendly staff, and pleasant (but not overpowering) musical ambiance. The chef has gone to the trouble of making the cuisine unique to Columbus by including references to and ingredients from well-known spots like Katzinger’s Deli and Ray Ray’s Hog Pit. The Neapolitan pizzas are 12 inches in diameter and serve six people.

15. Villa Nova Ristorante

• Address: 5545 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214
• Phone: (614) 846-5777

Huge servings of Italian and American cuisine and happy hour specials can be found at Villa Nova. Family-owned and operated, they serve the local community. Subs, spaghetti, and pizza are what they do best, and they’ve been dishing you delicious food for over 30 years. Villa Nova Ristorante serves Italian cuisine in Columbus, and its devotees claim it’s the greatest in the city (everywhere you’ll see great reviews). The pizzas and pasta at this restaurant are among the best I’ve ever had. It’s perfect for any meal of the day, from breakfast to lunch to a romantic Italian dinner.

This eatery has a well-stocked bar where you may enjoy a beverage with your meal. Little ones are encouraged to join their parents at the restaurant’s tables. Whether you’re dining alone or with a large party, Villa Nova Ristorante has plenty of seating available. Leave your finest clothes at home; Villa Nova Ristorante has a casual dress policy. Get takeout from here if you’re in a hurry. Many patrons choose to park nearby and walk to Villa Nova Ristorante for their meal at one of the best pizza places in Columbus.

Rounding Up

So, what are you waiting for? That was our list of the best pizza places in Columbus for you to start planning your next pizza night! And don’t forget to let us know which spot is your favorite. We always love trying new places to get our pizza fix!