15 Best Pizza Places in Tampa, Florida (2023)

When it comes to food, Tampa, Florida is definitely a city that knows how to pizza. From classic joints with deep-rooted histories to modern spots crafting trendy pies, this Sunshine State city has no shortage of delicious and affordable options for everyone’s favorite Italian dish. Here are 15 of the best pizza places in Tampa.

1. Due Amici Pizza & Pasta Bar

• Address: 1724 E 7th Ave, Tampa, FL 33605
• Phone: (813) 443-0906

Open late, this pizzeria serves New York City–style pizza, garlic knots, and beer, in addition to sandwiches and other snacks. Your choice of delivery or in-store pickup is available. Having trouble getting your Due Amici fix? Allow them to provide catering for your next event, and they guarantee that your visitors will be impressed by the delicious, freshly prepared cuisine. Ybor City is home to Due Amici, a family-run pizzeria and pasta bar. They put a lot of care into their dishes, down to the sauces that they make from scratch to go with the food.

Everything from the hand-spun dough to the freshest ingredients and the tender handling of the pies as they are transported to the oven is done in-house. San Marzano tomatoes, the main ingredient in their special pizza sauce, are farmed in the rich soil of Italy’s mountain valleys. It’s what gives their sauce that signature flavor you can taste in pizza and pasta meals. Using only the freshest ingredients, they can maintain the high standard of flavor that diners have come to expect from a top-tier establishment.

2. Eddie And Sam’s N.Y Pizza

• Address: 203 E Twiggs St, Tampa, FL 33602
• Phone: (813) 229-8500

Some people believe that you must eat at a dive to get the real deal when it comes to New York-style pizza. Eddie & Sam’s is the place for you if you fall into that category. The authenticity of the dish is boosted by the use of components such as New York water in the dough.

Sicilian pizzas, Hawaiian, and Primavera, along with hot and cold sandwiches, plus buffalo wings, are just a few of the options available on the menu, all of which emerge from the oven crisp and hot. The local office crowd has been flocking to Eddie & Sam’s for lunch for years, but late-night snackers staying in nearby downtown hotels will find that it’s conveniently located, too.

3. Grimaldi’s Pizzeria

• Address: 218 Westshore Plaza, Tampa, FL 33609
• Phone: (813) 287-2500

If you’re tired of the same old pizza at the same old chain restaurants, Grimaldi’s might be just what the doctor ordered. This award-winning restaurant in Tampa’s Westshore Mall is ideal for a work dinner or a romantic evening for two, as it is positioned close to both the shopping and business districts.

The first location opened near the Brooklyn Bridge, so you can bet that an authentic New York-style pizza is the specialty there. Fresh dough from their secret recipe is made daily, and only the finest ingredients are used in the pies before they are baked in a coal-fired brick oven. There is lots of inside and outside covered dining with a New York vibe that is both casual and classy.

4. Cappy’s Pizzeria

• Address: 3200 W Bay to Bay Blvd, Tampa, FL 33629
• Phone: (813) 835-0785

It’s a relaxed pizza joint that features a wide selection of pies and a throwback vibe thanks to the abundance of vintage signage and decor. The Tampa community may enjoy delicious salads, pizzas, and attentive service at this full-service pizzeria, which is open for both in-store and takeout orders. Cappy’s Pizza, established in Tampa, is a nationally recognized pizza brand. Even though there are now five sites in the Tampa Bay area, the original and most popular one remains in South Tampa. Pizza is the focus at Cappy’s, where you’ll find mainly that and a few side dishes like salads and calzones.

They excel in New York-style thin crust, yet this place is known as a deep dish paradise in Chicago. It’s like entering a pizzeria right next to Wrigley Field. The crust is doughy and coated with cheese initially, then sauce (as every deep dish connoisseur will tell us, that’s how it’s done). If you’re hoping for creative additions, this isn’t the place. Beer and wine are also available.

5. Tampa Pizza Co.

• Address: 777 N Ashley Drive, Suite C, Tampa, FL 33602
• Phone: (813) 463-1600

This family-run company has successfully established three locations in the city. This just proves how hard they work to make our delicious pies. Each dish, no matter how simple, is prepared with the same care and attention to detail and tastes just as good as it looks. Don’t take my word for it; see the hundreds of positive reviews already posted on Google and beyond. Aside from pizza, they serve a wide selection of appetizers, sandwiches, wraps, gelato, and more.

All-natural sodas, beers, and wines are available for purchase. There, visitors may relax in a modern setting while sharing delicious pizza. In keeping with Italian custom or using healthy substitutions to accommodate restricted diets. Every diner can find something to their liking at Tampa Pizza, as they have options for those who are lactose intolerant, vegetarian, soy-free, gluten-free, and vegan. They even provide convenient services like food delivery and catering.

6. Fabrica Pizza

• Address: 142 S Meridian Ave, Tampa, FL 33602
• Phone: (813) 605-0764

The atmosphere and flavor of a traditional Neapolitan pizzeria are brought to Fabrica. Their 00 flour dough, stretched by hand, is famous. The highest quality tomatoes are used in making their sauce. You can tell they mean it when they greet you with a grin and when they show you what a great deal they have for you because of the way they present the goods. This restaurant serves delicious food in a traditional Neapolitan way. Fabrica Woodfired Pizza, which began in Tampa in 2015, is an innovative take on the classic. It’s the perfect example of the current Italian fast casual experience, where tradition meets quality meets speed meets ease.

Here, tradition is preserved, ingredients are valued, and the preferences of their patrons are taken into account. Their menu centers on Neapolitan pizza, but they also provide salads, sandwiches, snacks, and desserts, all of which are prepared fresh and to order. Their customers are invited to peep into their kitchen whether they are eating in or ordering to go, swinging in for a glass of wine as well as a snack, or staying for an entire dinner, and they will always get the highest-quality meals at an affordable price.

Also read:

• 15 Best Pizza Places in Seattle, Washington (2022)
• 15 Best Pizza Places in Tucson, Arizona (2022)
• 15 Best Pizza Places in Virginia Beach, Virginia (2022)
• 15 Best Pizza Places in Des Moines, Iowa (2022)

7. Original Westshore Pizza South Tampa

• Address: 4802 W Bay Ct Ave, Tampa, FL 33611
• Phone: (813) 832-5331

This is a fast food restaurant chain known for its counter service and specialty pizzas, calzones, and Philly cheesesteaks. Westshore Pizza was established in 1994 to bring “The Taste of Philly” to Florida. Westshore Pizza has rapidly expanded over the past decade to become a leading pizza company in the United States. This pizzeria is well-known for its delicious pepperoni, cheesesteaks, and steaks.

Draft beer is a fantastic option among their drink offerings. Good lemonade will be provided for you. Westshore Pizza offers a convenient food delivery service. It has a very high level of hospitality, and the staff is quite patient. From the perspective of the guests, the pricing structure is fair. Guests have complimented the establishment for its warm ambiance. The Signature Works pizza, topped with HFG peppers, onions, mushrooms, sausage, pepperoni, and mozzarella and smothered in the restaurant’s exclusive Westshore pizza sauce, is a customer favorite. Check them out!

8. Magdalena’s Pizzeria

• Address: 2313 W Linebaugh Ave, Tampa, FL 33612
• Phone: (813) 252-7158

Magdalena’s Pizzeria is a locally owned Italian eatery that serves Subs, salads, wings, pizza, and more. Magdalena’s Pizzeria serves authentic Italian cuisine and is a must-try for any visitor to the city. They have delicious wings among other delectable options. Contact them today to order a lasagna pizza with mozzarella, ricotta, meatballs, sausage, and marinara sauce.

Magdalena’s Pizzeria in Tampa serves up delicious pizza, pasta, and wings baked from scratch daily. Subs, wings, stromboli, calzones, and specialty pizzas are just some of the items you’ll find on the extensive menu, which also includes daily specials. You can find them across the street from the Babe Zaharias Golf Club and adjacent to the 7-Eleven for lunch as well as dinner six days a week (except Mondays). You can either eat in or have it delivered or taken out, today.

9. Bella’s Italian Pizza

• Address: 1413 S Howard Ave Ste 100, Tampa, FL 33606
• Phone: (813) 254-3355

This casually chic institution serves both traditional Italian cuisine and individualized pasta dishes. Since opening in the 1980s, Bella’s has been a South Tampa institution. Pizza dough and spaghetti are made fresh every day, adding to the restaurant’s authentic, home-cooked taste. Many regulars come to enjoy the restaurant’s famous wood-fired pizzas and other authentic Italian specialties.

Bella’s welcomes its guests with an easy elegance thanks to the excellent design, dim lighting, and thoughtful touches. Both inside and outdoor guests can get a glimpse of the action in the open kitchen. Bella is popular with the post-club crowd because of its late hours and affordable costs.

10. Gourmet Pizza Company

• Address: 610 S Armenia Ave, Tampa, FL 33609
• Phone: (813) 258-1999

The pizza here is the most creative you’ll find anywhere in town. If you’re looking for a unique and high-quality pizza, look no further than Gourmet Pizza. Everyone is welcome, so don’t make the fancy name stress you out. We’re not saying that it’s extremely costly, that you need to make reservations, or that there’s a strict dress policy. Fresh, locally sourced, and mindfully prepared pie is the focus.

The menu features several vegan options, in addition to Cajun crawfish pizza and southwestern pizza, which are house specialties. You won’t be disappointed as the orders are always on par and the service excellent. Be careful following your directions, as the site is not readily visible between Dale Mabry Highway and downtown in the SoHo district (or just request delivery).

11. Anthony’s Coal-fired Pizza

• Address: 13020 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33618
• Phone: (813) 265-2625

There are three sites of Anthony’s Coal-Fired Pizza in the Tampa area. All of the pizzerias, including this one in Tampa’s Carrollwood neighborhood, are distinguished from competitors by their use of premium ingredients, traditional methods (including 800-degree coal-burning ovens), and attentive service.

The freshest mozzarella, a drizzle of olive oil, fresh basil, Romano cheese, and Italian plum tomatoes make these “well done” pies. Chicken wings and sandwiches grilled in a coal oven, along with traditional Italian fare like eggplant Marino, and ricotta cheese on hand-rolled meatballs round out the menu. For more information about their other Tampa locations, visit their website.

12. Wood Fired Pizza Wine Bar

• Address: 2822 E Bears Ave, Tampa, FL 33613
• Phone: (813) 341-2900

Here you may enjoy wood-fired pizzas, local beers, and fine wines in a chic and modern atmosphere. Wood Fired has drawn in locals and visitors alike as a popular hangout spot. Traditions from the past, handcrafted dishes, local beer and wine, a more relaxed pace, and a toast to simpler times are all part of the special and delightful experience they hope to provide for each other. It’s a hangout where people who value community can hang out and get to know one another over drinks and food.

In a casual, come-as-you-are atmosphere, they serve true artisan-style pizza made from scratch, along with fresh salads and specialty wines. At Wood Fired, patrons can choose from several different dining experiences, including sitting at one of the restaurant’s tiny tables, sipping wine in the restaurant’s quaint wine bar, or lounging on the restaurant’s year-round patio. Wood Fired is the proprietor’s way of giving back to the community and delighting in the company of all those who come in search of this humble yet globally popular peasant fare.

13. Bavaro’s Pizza

• Address: 514 N Franklin St #101, Tampa, FL 33602
• Phone: (813) 868-4440

Here you can enjoy Neapolitan pies and rustic pasta in a warm, welcoming atmosphere thanks to the brick walls and wood-fired oven at this Italian trattoria. This restaurant features the finest pizza in the world thanks to its traditional Neapolitan wood-fired brick oven. Its central location in downtown Tampa makes it convenient for both locals and visitors to explore the museums along the RiverWalk.

Thin and tender with slight crispiness, their crusts are topped with toppings that are brought from Naples or found locally. While other restaurants may offer more items on their menus, few serve pizzas on par with Bavaro’s. It’s possible that making a reservation is the only way to prevent a long wait.

14. Bernini of Ybor

• Address: 1702 E 7th Ave, Tampa, FL 33605
• Phone: (813) 242-9555

Italian specialties and wood-fired pizza are served at this café, along with brunch and happy hour menus. Bernini, as befits a location named after a prominent Italian sculptor, is trying for a more classical feel. The area may be filled with fine paintings and ornamental columns, but the gourmet cuisine is what we’re here for. Orange-glazed duck, black Angus beef, plus fresh fish are just some of the offerings.

The genuine wood-fired flatbread pizza as well as the luxurious martinis are the menu’s shining stars. Save space for dessert, because it offers new takes on old Italian standards. Dinner has live jazz music but lunch is more relaxed. It’s the perfect place to get pumped up before hitting Ybor City’s vibrant nightlife.

15. New York New York

• Address: 1512 E 7th Ave, Tampa, FL 33605
• Phone: (813) 248-1845

An informal pizzeria with a wide selection of sandwiches, wraps, burgers, and calzones. The New York New York Pizza restaurant is a hotspot for clubgoers looking to refuel with a late-night slice due to its convenient location in the middle of Ybor City’s lively nightlife zone. There is a walk-up window for individuals who are in a rush to get home. Chicken wings, salads, Italian subs, and spaghetti dinners are just a few of the many options available on their large menu, all of which are prepared in-house from scratch.

People from all over the world travel here to enjoy New York-style pizza. Most people think it tastes great, and they love the wide variety of toppings and the thin, crunchy crust. The pizza is so good that they’ve had to open several other locations that you’ll find on their website. You can visit with friends or family or simply dine solo. Either way, you’re in for a treat.

Rounding up

Whether you’re a local looking for a new spot to try or you’re visiting and want to sample some of the best that this fantastic city has to offer, our list of the best pizza places is sure to tick a box!

Let us know in the comments which are your favorite!?