15 Best Pizza Places in Cleveland, Ohio (2023)

In Cleveland, Ohio, there is no shortage of pizza places to choose from. Whether you’re in the mood for classic New York-style pizza or something a bit more creative, these 15 spots will have you covered.

So next time you’re looking for some delicious and cheesy comfort food, check out one of these pizza places. You won’t be disappointed!

1. Il Rione

• Address: 1303 W. 65th – Gordon Square, Cleveland, OH
• Phone: (216) 282-1451

The pizzeria is housed in a remodeled bar from 1917 and serves New York City-style pizzas with creative toppings. An excellent brick-oven pizza is baked in front of your eyes while you enjoy live music and premium drinks at this restaurant. The clam dish with garlic and pecorino is a must-try! The speck with the heated honey, lemon ricotta, pistachio, and paper-thin ham slices is also worth your time to read. Wood-fired New York-style pizza is made by owners Brian Holleran and Brian Moss, who use only a few classic ingredients like arugula and prosciutto.

The new West 65th Street pizza is a cozy spot where original materials and contemporary finishes combine to create an atmosphere that is both welcoming and full of character. Customers can watch their pizzas being made thanks to the open layout of the kitchen and bar. The artwork and the building’s original features, such as the brick walls and rafters, allude to a bygone age in Cleveland.

2. Dina’s Pizza & Pub

• Address: 5701 Memphis Avenue, Cleveland, OH
• Phone: (216) 351-3663

Pizza, pub food, beer, wine, and house martinis can all be found at this former gas station turned restaurant. For families, they’ve got high seats at the ready. This friendly, low-key spot has a bar right on the premises. There’s a wide variety of pasta entrees, pizzas, appetizers, and sweets to choose from on the menu. If you’re ever in Cleveland, don’t miss out on Dina’s Pizza & Pub’s delicious selection. Experience the world a little more by trying their wonderful seafood.

Crab rangoons, Strombolis, and pepperoni pizzas are all delicious options. Good cheesecakes are something that most visitors recommend you try. Delicious brews on tap, liqueurs, and wines are available here. This restaurant offers takeout services. The staff is helpful and quick to respond. It’s clear that this pub has a high standard for great service, given how quickly customers are attended to. It has been said that the costs here are very reasonable. The inviting decor is sure to win you over. Feel free to drop over with the whole gang and sample their fare. They provide over 20 different varieties of hot and mild wings, and they always sell out during hockey season.

3. Pizza Whirl

• Address: 1822 W 25th, Cleveland, OH 44113
• Phone: (216) 242-6464

A casual restaurant with exposed brick and a menu centered on making your version of traditional and original pizzas. Do you feel like eating at a fantastic neighborhood restaurant that serves tasty meals made with high-quality ingredients yet doesn’t break the bank? If so, you’ve come to the right place. Guests can take their delicious meals with them to eat whenever and wherever they like. There are many tantalizing options, including house-made specialties, on the menu.

They are committed to providing patrons with exceptional meals. The nutella ricotta cheese pizza featuring fresh strawberries, bananas, raspberry drizzle, and chocolate should not be missed. There is outside seating, the vibe is relaxed and family-friendly, and you can bring the kids. You can find vegetarian selections for lunch and supper, as well as dessert. It’s common to encounter tour groups, students, and visitors like yourself.

4. Citizen Pie

• Address: 15710 Waterloo Rd #11660, Cleveland, OH
• Phone: (216) 417-2742

Citizen Pie is known for its authentic wood-fired Neapolitan pizza and lively, vibrant atmosphere. Since they provide alcohol, this eatery is great for after-work get-togethers with friends. The mushroom and brie pie is my go-to from the brick oven since it’s one of a kind, substantial, exciting, and delicious.

There’s no mistake about what you’re getting into at Citizen Pie, a tiny eatery with a massive pizza oven. This is one of the greatest Neapolitan-style pizzas in town, with its doughy, charred crust and premium toppings. Don’t pass on the simple, yet ideal, combination of smoked pepperoni, mozzarella, and oregano on a basic pizza.

5. City Slice Pizzeria

• Address: 12021 Lorain Ave, Cleveland, OH 04111
• Phone: (216) 273-7504

This minority-owned, family-operated pizzeria in Cleveland is committed to bringing a taste of New York to the area with its homemade pies and gigantic slices. City Slice, in case you haven’t heard, makes the largest slices in the area. Slices of pizza and ice cream are also on the menu. The arcade games available there are fun for everyone in the family. If you’re looking for something different, we recommend the Veggie City pie, which comes with your choice of provolone or mozzarella, red sauce, Roma tomatoes, black olives, mushrooms, green peppers, and onion.

Their 40-inch pies are so huge that even a single piece is bigger than a traditional Neapolitan pizza. The thin and chewy crust can be folded without breaking, keeping the pizza from falling over, yet it is still substantial enough to hold the toppings. Ordering a whole 18-inch pizza for pickup or delivery is an option, but the larger 40-inch pies are not. Do yourself a favor and order the cherry pepper pie, which is sure to please.

6. Cent’s Pizza + Goods

• Address: 5010 Lorain Ave, Cleveland, OH 44102
• Phone: (216) 862-6427

This pizzeria is the place to be. After working at the legendary Roberta’s Pizza in New York City, founder Vincent Morelli opened a pizzeria in Ohio City. The pink-themed pizzeria is now up for business, complete with a sizzling Italian wood oven. A large screen plays vintage films while a constantly playing soundtrack makes you feel cooler than you are. No liquor license as of yet, so BYOB, but there’s plenty of food to go around. Toppings like Parmesan cheese and anchovies are optional on the tomato pizza, which also comes with garlic, oregano, extra-virgin olive oil, and breadcrumbs.

Salads, such as the Deep House Salad with olive oil, red wine vinegar, dill, and frisee endive, are also available in addition to the four pizza options. Vince Morelli, the man behind Cent’s Pizza & Goods, has made it his mission to improve the quality of life in Cleveland, and he’s doing it one slice at a time. Friday through Sunday, you can order pizza to-go there. Because of how popular it will be, the first weekend is completely sold out. Olive oil, basil, ricotta, and even anchovies are just a few of the unconventional pizza toppings that can be found on Cent’s menu.

7. Vero Pizza Napoletana

• Address: 12421 Cedar Rd, Cleveland Heights, OH 44106
• Phone: (216) 229-8383

This trendy bi-level restaurant is known for its creative pizzas topped with in-season produce. You’ll see the wood-burning oven, 6000-pound equipment imported from Italy, with Vero tiled in navy above its opening, before you’ll notice the abstract artworks that dominate the 40-seat dining area or the sleek maple bar. Marc-Aurele Buholzer, a pizza chef, serves the beast 100 pizzas per day at a rate of three pizzas at a time. The baking time for the dough is a scant 90 seconds. Cleveland’s best pizza has a dark, charred crust that’s still sweet and chewy.

The modern Napoletana cuisine is uncomplicated but impressive; the Margherita, with its weekly shipment of buffalo mozzarella from Italy, is a particular standout. As an example, a simple but delicious appetizer is buffalo mozzarella topped with grated cured egg yolk and olive oil. The prosciutto has been aged for 36 months. Still, the fact that they offer a Milk ‘n’ Honey made with egg and hot honey demonstrates that they can laugh at themselves.

Also read:

• 15 Best Pizza Places in Tucson, Arizona (2022)
• 15 Best Pizza Places in Seattle, Washington (2022)
• 15 Best Pizza Places in Tampa, Florida (2022)
• 15 Best Pizza Places in Nashville, Tennessee (2022)

8. Crust Midtown

• Address: 3000 St Clair Ave NE, Cleveland, OH
• Phone: (216) 589-9711

At this eatery, you may eat only one of the enormous and delicious pizzas and be well satisfied. Although there is seating inside this casual eatery, I recommend ordering to go so that you may enjoy your meal at a neighboring park on a lovely day. Since their cheese is so good, I suggest ordering a plain pepperoni pizza with red sauce.

The New York-style pizza isn’t the only good thing about this place; the stacked subs and ricotta gnocchi are delicious, too. All of their citywide locations are well-regarded by patrons. Crust initially just served pizza, but eventually began serving other Italian dishes like pasta, arancini with marinara, sub sandwiches, and burgers. Both a Greek spanakopita pizza with feta, spinach, and garlic and an eggplant pizza made with roasted eggplant are among the specialties featuring smoked mozzarella, red peppers, balsamic reduction. Griffin is thinking about opening a third Crust in 2023.

9. Moe’s Tavern

• Address: 1740 E 17th St, Cleveland, OH 44114
• Phone: (440) 525-1041

This legendary watering hole served as inspiration for Moe’s in the first season of The Simpsons. The brewpub serves retro-style sourdough pizza, pub bites, plus beverages. The greatest 10 bars and best 20 restaurants in Cleveland. The happy hour menu and sports viewing are not kid-friendly, but you can bring your drinks. The staff is kind and helpful, the beer selection is excellent, and there are perks like free wifi and a trivia night.

Try the Moe’s Flaming Chicken or fish sandwich. Their 10″ Neapolitan pizzas are baked in a 550° clay oven and come out with the right crispiness and soft interior. The Quattro Formaggio pizza is a must topped with Parmesan, feta, mozzarella, and provolone. The Meat at Moe’s is also very popular with its provolone or mozzarella, bacon, sausage, and pepperoni toppings. While there are only two salad options, they’re pretty good.

10. Astoria Cafe & Market

• Address: 5417 Detroit Ave, Cleveland, OH 44102
• Phone: (216) 266-0834

A chic Mediterranean market and restaurant serving tapas, wine, and cocktails alongside a selection of fine meats and cheeses. Chef Cory Kobrinski claims that Astoria never intended to become one of Cleveland’s finest dining establishments. In 2016, the 5,000-square-foot building near Gordon Square was known more for the vast warehouse of specialized foods housed within than for the cozy cafe. Customers, however, are king, and they gradually started to expect more from Kobrinski’s market-driven, Greek-inspired restaurant.

Now, there’s room for 240 people inside. Astoria is a pulsating hub of activity at all hours of the day and night. In contrast, the brunch at Astoria is usually considered to be among the greatest in all of Cleveland. With imported Italian ham flavored with rosemary, Swiss gruyere, homemade bechamel, mustard, plus an egg, the Croque Madame is like the market’s greatest hits.

11. Edison’s Pizza Kitchen

• Address: 2365 Professor Ave, Cleveland, OH 44113
• Phone: (216) 298-4484

Cozy, functional pizzeria serving up pizza, subs, and typical sides like wings and salads. Our local bar is warm and welcoming. Even though this is predominantly a craft beer bar, I would recommend coming here for the pizza. It’s great when a bar offers more than just the standard bar fare like fries plus chicken wings. Their pizza is top-notch down to the crunchy dough and salty cheese. Plus, I enjoy the weekly live entertainment on Saturdays as well as the weekly dance parties on Mondays.

In addition, your canine companion is welcome to join you on the outdoor patio. A place opens late where you can get pieces of specialty pies to go. After an overly celebratory night of drinking, one of Edison’s rich, thick pies is just what the physician ordered. Edison is known for its specialty pies, which are well worth the time (as well as the late hours), but the restaurant also offers ample slices for those in a rush. BBQ chicken with a special sauce created from scratch, onions, a cheese blend, and honey on the side for dipping.

12. Athens Pizzeria

• Address: 4341 Rocky River Dr, Cleveland, OH 44135
• Phone: (216) 476-1944

Here you can get thick-crust pizza and Greek dishes like gyros and baklava in a relaxed setting that has been around for quite some time. Athens Pizzeria cares about its pizzas because the toppings are finely diced and spread evenly. There is a plethora of highly recommended spots to choose from. In addition to a delicious pizza, their eatery also boasts an abundance of delicious toppings, friendly and attentive service, and a comfortable, relaxed atmosphere.

Check out Athens Pizzeria for a full meal or a quick slice and experience the restaurant’s various healing properties for yourself! Interested in learning about the meal options? Have a look at the fantastic pizzas and the many different kinds of appetizers they have to offer. There’s something for everyone there, from vegans to carnivores. If you’re feeling hungry, drop by for a pie or bring the entire family in for supper.

13. Dewey’s Pizza

• Address: 3014 Madison Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45209
• Phone: (513) 731-7755

An unpretentious pizza restaurant based in the Midwest, known for its creative custom pies and rotating tap list of local brews. Pizza may be the star of the show, but calzones and salads aren’t to be overlooked. With 24 locations across the Midwest, Dewey’s Pizza is a high-end casual gourmet pizza chain. We have been serving up unique pizzas, salads, and craft beers from the area for over twenty years. Their friendly service, paired with music selected just for them, will elevate your pizza-eating experience to new heights.

You can customize your pizza however you like. You might even get a specialty pizza like the “Edgar Allen Poe,” which is topped with olive oil, goat cheese, olives, mushrooms, and more. While pizza restaurants often offer salads to complement their pies, Dewey’s goes well beyond the standard lettuce, tomato, and cheese plate by offering creative options like the “Candied Walnut & Grape” and the “Peppercorn Ranch.” You can get your food to go from Dewey’s, or eat in the trendy, spotless restaurant. Dewey’s is still casual dining, but it’s a cut beyond your average pizzeria. They have eight different beers on tap along with wine by the bottle or glass.

14. Mamma Santa’s

• Address: 12301 Mayfield Rd, Cleveland, OH 44106
• Phone: (216) 231-9567

A time-honored, family-run establishment known for its authentic Italian fare and checkered tablecloths. Mamma Santa has always been found at the same address. The structure has stood for more than a century. The Sicilian dishes on the menu are made using traditional family traditions. The meals are fresh and delicious because they were prepared from scratch. There’s no complicated menu here, simply classic pizzas topped with tasty ingredients like pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, sausage, and pepperoncini.

Pasta, sandwiches, as well as appetizers, are some of the other choices. Danny and Anthony, sons of the restaurant’s founders, started working there while they were teenagers. Pina, Anthony’s wife, is responsible for all of the restaurant’s daily handcrafted dough, sauces, and pasta. Besides Anthony, all four of his kids have jobs at the eatery. If you’re looking for genuine, old-school pizza in Cleveland, your best bet is Mamma Santa’s.

15. Scotti’s Italian Eatery

• Address: 882 E 185th St, Cleveland, OH 44119
• Phone: (216) 481-8995

Cozy Italian restaurant serving pizza, spaghetti, salads, and more with outdoor dining and a full bar. They’ve been a go-to for traditional Italian fare and friendly service since 1912. This pizza place serves delicious authentic Italian food. At Scotti’s Italian Eatery, patrons can get delicious calzone pizza, calzones plus ravioli. Tasty ice cream or cannolis with lemon filling is in order.

You might hear someone saying how great the beer is. The excellent service and helpful staff here have made this establishment famous. According to the reviews, the costs are reasonable. The sleek furnishings and calming ambiance create an ideal spot to unwind.

Rounding up

Enjoyed our list? Already been to any of them? We hope we haven’t missed any out – but if we have, let us know in the comments (and tell us which your fave one is too!)